Log boats and boulders in the Boyne?

Two cutmarks on a piece of wood do not make it a part of a sea-going stone transport vessel.......

There is quite a bit of media coverage today for this story.  Interesting, but a degree of caution is needed.  Some old bits of timber with "cut marks" on them may or may not indicate the presence of log boats.  They may just be bits and pieces of trunk or branches associated with forest clearance, that have found their way into the river and its sediments.  More evidence required on that front....  what degree of strangeness is required for something to be classed as "an anomaly"?

And the "16 items which appear to be large boulders or rocks" found in the sediments -- how anomalous are they?  How big are they? And what makes them different in kind or origin from the boulders inevitably sitting in sea-bed or estuary-bed sediments as a result of the area's very substantial glacial legacy?  Do the archaeologists recognize Irish till when they see it?

So there are echoes here of the wild media frenzy of several decades ago, when some boulders were found on the bed of Milford Haven?  one of them, at the time, was instantly deemed bu museum curator Robert Kennedy (and many others) to be "the missing bluestone" from Stonehenge, which was lost from a raft and had to be replaced with a chunk of Cosheston sandstone from the seashore of the Daugleddau estuary.  Some people apparently still take this fantasy seriously........

Anyway, the Boyne research is interesting, and we await further publications.  At the moment, there is nothing in print which suggests that these pieces of wood are the remnabts of log boats or rafts, nothing to suggest that the timber bits and the boulders are related, and nothing to show that the boulders or the bits of wood have anything to do with either Newgrange or any other prehistoric site.

================

Archaeologists say they've discovered what could be Neolithic log boats near Newgrange

https://www.thejournal.ie/newgrange-archaeologists-neolithic-boats-boyne-4878107-Nov2019/

The river bed of the Boyne is being searched by archaeologists.

ARCHAEOLOGISTS HAVE IDENTIFIED what could be Neolithic log boats as well as boulders, perhaps intended to be used in the building of Newgrange or Knowth, in the river bed of the Boyne, near to the famous monuments.

The survey of the river, believed to be the first of its kind, is the work of a team of researchers from UCD’s School of Archaeology and Ulster University’s School of Geography and Environmental Science, funded by the Royal Irish Academy.
They are focused on the river bed where it runs through the Brú na Bóinne World Heritage Site and are part of a project to focus on role of the Boyne which is at the heart of the ‘Bend in the Boyne’.

The research is led by Dr Stephen Davis, UCD School of Archaeology, who said that despite being a key thoroughfare and trade route over millennia “our understanding of the river was identified in the 2009 Brú na Bóinne Research Framework as a major knowledge gap”.
“This work is very valuable and like so much of the non-invasive work we have been doing in Brú na Bóinne over the last decade it helps us build the foundations from which we can really begin to understand the landscape,” he said about this latest research.
“The project had three main aims: to undertake new mapping of the river channel and to potentially identify new archaeological features, to explore the landscape of the river at Brú na Bóinne using Geographic Information Systems and to collate local folklore relating to the Boyne from the Schools’ Collection to better understand the Boyne in its local context,” David said.
The results of the surveys have not disappointed and come just months after other non-invasive work discovered 40 previously unknown monuments close to Newgrange.
In addition to learning more about the structure of the river, this latest research has so far identified 100 items of interest in a 10km stretch.

“These items may or may not be archaeological, but we can say for certainty that they don’t belong there, they are things that are out of the ordinary and would benefit from further analysis,” Davis said.
Ten of them appear to be “log boat type anomalies and there have been log boats, including one that dated from the Neolithic era, found in the Boyne before”.
There are also 16 items which appear to be large boulders or rocks and Davis said that “if we are thinking of somewhere where people were potentially moving large stones up and down to build monuments with then it is almost certain that some of these were lost in the Boyne on their way to being used in construction”.
It is highly unlikely that one of the log boats could have transported large rocks or boulders, but archaeologists think that rafts may have been used.
The surveys also found weirs, accumulations of debris that could have an archaeological importance and some 31 very modern tyres.
The team also explored the relationship of the Boyne to the monument location using data gathered over a number of seasons of large-scale survey and existing airborne laser scanning surveys.
“These analyses highlight the importance of visibility from the river for site placement, especially in regard to the Neolithic passage tombs and timber monuments,” Davis said.
“The Neolithic landscape is very much constructed around the river. For an observer from the river, the ridge on which Newgrange, Knowth and Dowth are located would have formed a northern barrier beyond which there was no visibility. To the south the steep slopes again block the observer’s views,” he added.
Davis was also involved in the 2017 research which uncovered what he described as a “spectacular” monument beside Newgrange – it also appears aligned with the Winter Solstice sunrise.
The research findings will be part of a temporary exhibition, featuring key project results, to be housed in the newly redeveloped OPW Brú na Bóinne visitor centre.