THE BOOK
Some of the ideas discussed in this blog are published in my new book called "The Stonehenge Bluestones" -- available by post and through good bookshops everywhere. Bad bookshops might not have it....
To order, click
HERE

Saturday, 21 November 2026

Prof Peter Worsley slams Stonehenge "establishment mafia" and "poppycock science"




Well, that was interesting.   On 19 Nov I joined a Zoom session  for a lecture given by Prof Peter Worsley to the members of the Warwickshire Geological Conservation Group  (WGCG) in Kenilworth.  It was not recorded, and the presentation was not helped by assorted Zoom technical glitsches -- but I heard most of the talk and saw most of the slides, I think........

Peter and I go back a long way -- we were research students at the same time, working on quite similar topics.  And crossing swords with Prof Fred Shotton!  We have kept in touch over the years. After a long academic career in Reading University Peter is now Emeritis Professor of Quaternary Geology.

The talk was entitled "Geology of Stonehenge and the Bluestone Controversy" and it covered the local geology of Salisbury Plain, the sarsens, the bluestones and (as a separate item) the Altar Stone controversy.  As befits an Emeritus Professor, Peter did not pull his punches.  

In the first section of his lecture Peter referred to his studies on the sarsens at Clatford Bottom and elsewhere and suggested that there was once a substantial litter of sarsens in the Stonehenge landscape, with many monoliths of different shapes and sizes used at Stonehenge for a monument which was never completed. Now where have we heard that before? He suggested a strong link with the remnants of the Reading Formation at Sidbury Hill and elsewhere and with the clay-with-flints deposits which are ubiquitous.  He was not at all convinced by the work suggesting a West Woods source for many of the sarsens, and said that the obsession with working out haulage routes was "rather crazy."  

The Zoom feed of this part of the lecture was very broken up, and I should like to know more about Peter's arguments......

On the bluestones, Peter expressed his support for the work of Judd, Kellaway, Burl and the OU team who all thought that the bluestones were glacially transported and derived from largely destroyed glacial deposits in the vicinity of Stonehenge.  He seemed genuinely mystified as to why HH Thomas (a geologist) had in 1923 entered "fantasy land" by saying glacial transport of the bluestones was impossible and that human transport must therefore have happened. He was also mystified as to the reasons why geologists Ixer and Bevins had so enthusiastically "jumped into bed" with Parker Pearson and his team of archaeologists -- which he referred to as the establishment "mafia."  

Peter referred to me and my books, and suggested that "The Stonehenge Bluestones" had been banned from the Reading University archaeology department and from the Stonehenge Visitor Centre.  I don't know whether that is true, but I would not be surprised........  And his slide of him and me (referred to as "old codgers") in my bluestone museum from a few years ago  is rather splendid.

The so-called bluestone quarries have been personally investigated in the field by Peter, and last evening he referred to the Carn Goedog and Craig Rhosyfelin quarries as "absolute nonsense" and "poppycock".  He referred to the "mythical" Waun Mawn lost circle as "total fantasy".  He accused the BBC, in that appalling Alice Roberts documentary, of a very serious dereliction of its duty and a decline of standards, saying that "the whole thing is fiction".   And he sprang to my defence concerning the "really nasty" activities of Bevins and his lynch mob on the matter of the Newall Boulder. Their extraordinary behaviour, he said, brought them no credit whatsoever.

A reminder:

https://brian-mountainman.blogspot.com/2025/07/the-stonehenge-lynch-mob-marches-out.html

Turning to the wild twists and turns in the debate over the origin of the Altar Stone, he was again scathing about the poor quality of work done by Clarke and Kirkland,  Bevins, Ixer and others.   I got a clear impression that he was frustrated and even irritated by the premature publication of half-baked papers, by the use of surrogate samples, and by the lack of fieldwork.  He was particularly critical of   the "Dogger Land" hypothesis which predated the latest paper by Pirrie et al. 

The outcome of all this, of course, is that  we are no further forward now than we were in 1923 concerning the origin of the Altar Stone.

In his last section Peter also poured scorn on the paper by Clarke and Kirkland in which they claimed that the zircon evidence from Salisbury Plain stream sediments ruled out the glacial transport of materials onto Salisbury Plain from the west.  He referred to the paper as "useless rubbish".  

In his summary Peter accused the human transport proponents of "intransigence" and of having vested interests in keeping their hypothesis alive.  There was, he said, an obsession with the telling of a good story, and a willingness to ignore or belittle inconvenient but sound scientific work in pursuit of that aim.

So there we are then.  

By the way, I rather like being referred to as a "glacialist".  Much more refined and genteel than being called a glaciologist or a geomorphologist.

On a personal note, it's gratifying that senior academics like Peter Worsley and Peter Kokelaar are now going on the record and speaking their minds. I know of many others who agree with them, but who prefer to keep silent because they are concerned about job security or because they think they do not know enough about the matter in hand to say anything meaningful.  So here is a message to glacial geologists, geomorphologists and archaeologists everywhere -- for God's sake contribute to the debate, and call out nonsense when you see it!




Tuesday, 17 November 2026

The Ramson Cliff erratic: analysis of a fresh sample


Close-up of part of the latest sample from the problematical erratic

It's always good to have second opinions, and I have received a brief report kindly prepared bt Prof Jonathan Slack. It's based on a small sample supplied by Paul Madgett. In its essentials the report agrees with the report published by Daw, Ixer and Madgett, although Prof Slack is less sure about an origin in Devon or Cornwall. So the provenance issue is still wide open.  Watch this space.

Some details in the report are still being checked, and we hope to publish it in due course.

The new sample comes from a second fragment, also collected by Paul, and not previously subjected to detailed analysis.

One thing to note when comparing the images from this report with that published back in the summer on this blog:


There are clear differences in the colour balance across the two samples.  These do not necessarily demonstrate petrological differences, but reflect the colour balance variations across several different computers which are beyond my technical ability to correct!!


====================================================================

Ramson Cliff Erratic Saunton, Devon, SS 4356 4070 

==================================================================





We will welcome expert opinion on the features seen in these slides.  Just add your comments and submit them as usual.  


Monday, 16 November 2026

Instant portrait


I gave my talk at Rhosygilwen yesterday afternoon, and while I was nattering on for 65 mins, and trying to cope with assorted digital slide projector malfunctions, resident artist Raphaelle Fieldhouse managed to produce this instant portrait of me.  How did she manage to do that, while I was hopping about, gesticulating and turning this way and that?  I am very impressed by her talents.   Not very flattering, to my mind, but artists have to be allowed to do their own thing.........

Friday, 13 November 2026

Surging behaviour on Oxford Glacier: Brian Hughes and the Hudgeometer

This post is dedicated to the memory of our dear friend Brian Hughes, who sadly passed away on 25th September 2026.


========================



Brian was the inventor and maker of a scientific instrument which we used for the measurement of ice temperatures on the Oxford Glacier in East Greenland in August 1962.  We believe that these readings were the first ever obtained in Greenland from the surface of a surging glacier. 

See these posts:







When we were planning the Oxford University Expedition to East Greenland David Sugden and I decided that we wanted to make some glaciological observations on a small glacier somewhere within our field area.  Originally we planned to work on a steep glacier on the west side of Nordvestfjord, but as soon as we saw it from a distance it was clear that it was too large and too heavily crevassed to work on safely, given our limited manpower resources and rather primitive equipment.  So we decided instead to visit a small glacier on the eastern flank of the fjord -- in a valley just to the north of the great diffluent trough of Holger Danskes Briller.  (This glacier was in 1962 identified by the informal name of Uranus Gletscher. ) We moved our equipment up the fjord by kayak, in a journey described in this video called "Into the World's Longest Fjord":

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zaF5J4KcQGw&t=79s

In addition to all our ropes, ice axes, crampons etc we carried onto the glacier our simple aluminium drilling equipment and the Hudgeometer in its wooden box.  It's a miracle that it all survived -- but after parachute drops and a great deal of rough handling, we were half expecting that the delicate gadget needed for the ice temperature measurements might have been damaged irreperably.  But we had to give it a go.......


Carrying our ice drilling and other equipment on the highly pitted and irregular surface of Oxford Glacier, August 1962.



Svend Wurm about to use the ice drilling equipment at one of the selected sampling sites

In the event, we managed to drill 17 holes on the glacier surface, designed to sample different parts of the glacier.  Because of the inadequacies of our drilling equipment, we never managed to drill down to more than c 4m -- but we did manage to get lots of temperature readings using a thermistor probe on the end of a cable, reading the results off a dial on the Hudgeometer. 

The drilling programme came to an abrupt end when the drill stuck in hole 18 and we found it impossible to get it out.  We tried to melt the drill rods out with the aid of warm liquid (guess where that came from!), all to no avail.  So the rods were abandoned in the hole, and that was the end of our glaciology programme.

Anyway, the results were chaotic, and no matter how much we tried to see patterns and trends in the data, we were flummoxed.  David and I concluded, reluctantly, that the Hudgeometer was giving us false results, possibly because of a calibration error by Brian back in Oxford,   or (more likely) because of some damage done to the equipment during or after transport from the UK to Greenland.  Somewhat disappointed, we walked off the glacier through pits and chasms that were typical of surging glaciers (although we did not know it at the time) and travelled by kayak next day back to our base camp area in Kjove Land.

In the later analysis of our results we could not work out what was happening to the surface layers of ice on the glacier, and because of the strong chance of equipment malfunctions we never did publish our results.  We brought the Hudgeometer back home with us at the end of the expedition, but we have no idea where it is now.  Maybe in an attic, somewhere...........  but it should be in a Museum!! 

We are not sure when, or how, our small glacier was given the official name of "Oxford Gletscher" by the Greenland place names authority.  We had nothing to do with it -- but maybe Svend Wurm made representations in Denmark, having realised, better than we did, that our glaciology results were actually quite significant?

So there we are then.  Our dear friend Brian made a small but not insignificant contribution (a) to the first discovery of a chaotic surging glacier thermal regime in Greenland, and (b) to the naming of the Oxford Glacier as a tribute to the university.  Had he known it, he would no doubt have been very chuffed.


Running repairs to Sandy's sledge, on which we hauled our camping and glaciology 
equipment up the glacier

==================================

PS.  Why was the machine called "The Hudgeometer" ??  It's a bit complicated.  In our gang of very close friends in Jesus College in 1959-62 which we referred to as The Councule, there were two Brians.  To avoid confusion I was genarally called "BJ" and Brian H was referred to as "Hudges".  His wonderful thermocouple machine, fabricated in the spring of 1962, was naturally enough then referred to as "The Hudgeometer".............

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

The "Scottish Origin" of the Altar Stone: much mud on faces



The broken Altar Stone beneath sarsen stone 55b.  Did any of the assumed Altar Stone 
samples actually come from the recumbent monolith?

So here is the new paper we have been waiting for, introducing some common sense to the over-excited debate about the so-called "Scottish Origin" of the Altar Stone.   Many thanks for Prof Andy Morton for sending me a copy.

Details:

Searching for the origin of the Stonehenge Altar Stone: new sedimentological, petrographical, mineralogical, geochemical and isotopic constraints
Pirrie D et al, Journal of the Geological Society183 (2026) jgs2026-090, pp 1-19
https://doi.org/10.1144/jgs2026-090

Abstract: 
Accurately constraining the provenance of geological materials from archaeological contexts is critical for the subsequent interpretation of their significance. Stonehenge, the iconic Neolithic monument on Salisbury Plain, is significant in terms of well-documented long-distance transport of geological materials used in its construction, with many of the bluestones transported c. 225 km from West Wales. One stone at Stonehenge, the Altar Stone, is distinctive in terms of its composition, being composed of a well-sorted fine- to very fine-grained calcite-cemented sandstone. Its purpose at the monument, and when it was transported to the site, is unknown. Early interpretations of a provenance from West Wales have previously been discounted based on both geochemical and mineralogical data. More recently, the age of detrital zircon, rutile and apatite grains in the Altar Stone were used to infer a provenance from the Orcadian Basin of NE Scotland. This paper presents a detailed multi-proxy characterization of the sedimentology, geochemistry, detrital and diagenetic mineralogy of the Altar Stone based on both in situ analysis along with the analysis of museum samples confidently attributed to the Altar Stone, as direct sampling is not possible. While the previously published detrital grain dating supports a Laurentian source for the heavy minerals present in the Altar Stone, the overall petrology, heavy mineral assemblage, clay mineralogy and geochemistry show that many outcrops of the Old Red Sandstone (ORS) in the Orcadian Basin could not have been the source of the Altar Stone. To date, no examined outcrop area of the UK ORS can be shown to have the same suite of lithological and geochemical characteristics as documented for the Altar Stone. Consequently, this integrated dataset shows that the exact provenance of the Altar Stone is as yet unknown.

This is a multi-authored work, including Bevins, Ixer, Pearce and Pirrie who were involved in the ill-advised and very premature 2024 suggestion -- heavily hyped in the media -- that the Altar Stone had probably come from the Orcadian Basin of NE Scotland. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07652-1       (They had also been involved in the "initial suggestion" that the Altar Stone had not come from Wales or the Welsh Borderlands, in The Journal of Archaeological Science in 1923.) https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352409X23003905 

In a follow-up paper building on the claim (in late 2024) they asked "Was the Stonehenge Altar Stone from Orkney?" (Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports, Vol. 58).  Bevins, Pearce, Pirrie, Ixer, and colleagues tested mainland Orkney monuments and outcrops. They ruled out Orkney specifically, shifting their focus to the Scottish mainland portion of the Orcadian Basin.

Then there was a wider archaeological synthesis in December 2024.  In "Stonehenge and its Altar Stone: the significance of distant stone sources" (Archaeology International, Vol. 27), Parker Pearson, Bevins, Bradley, Ixer, Pearce, and Richards used the 2024 Nature claim to argue that Stonehenge was built as a monument of island-wide Neolithic unification. Fanciful twaddle, but guaranteed to garner lots of attention in the mnedia.......


I said in a blog post on 4th September 2026:  As we know from a vast media campaign and from abundant posts on this blog, the idea that the Stonehenge Altar Stone (stone 80) came from "Orcadian" NE Scotland is now taken as an accepted truth. There have been some differences in interpretation from the Bevins - Ixer - Pearce team and the Clarke and Kirkland team, but their papers make some pretty brash claims which have never been properly interrogated in the specialist literature. Well, all that is changing, and with a number of geologists now working on the case, I predict that the whole edifice of the "Scottish Altar Stone" will soon come crashing down.

Prophecy fulfilled.

As readers of this blog will know, I heavily criticised these papers at the time they were published, in these and other posts.

My main concerns were, and still are, to do with the use of surrogate samples that might have come from the Altar Stone, or maybe not.  I have also been concerned with the quality of the science used in support of some pretty outrageous claims -- with a small number of field samples (and more often samples cited in other studies) erroneously taken as representative of vast numbers of outcrops and vast swathes of territory.n  The creating and analysis of aggregate samples is another issue.

I will look at this paper in another post -- and I do not accept for a moment the feeble excuse from Bevins, Ixer and Co that their previous deeply misleading and speculative publications were just part of a process of standard scientific elimination in a systematic search for the truth. Their approach is altogether too cavalier and too irresponsible.   In their frantic search for media headlines and popular praise they keep on getting things hopelessly wrong, bringing science itself into disrepute.

It should be noted that the highly critical  riposte of Ciborowsky and Nash (2026) -- which exposed a number of fatal flaws in the proxy Altar Stone data used by Bevins, Ixer et al -- was published too late to be incorporated and properly cited in the latest JGS article.  We have certainly not heard the last of that particular spat -- but the message from Ciborowski and Nash is essentially the same as that of the new article -- namely that the database is simply too flimsy to demonstrate any link between the Altar Stone and Scotland.

https://brian-mountainman.blogspot.com/2026/09/stone-62-nice-academic-spat-about.html
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352409X26004475?via%3Dihub

One last point.  The eight "Altar Stone" samples that are analysed in this new study are all accepted by the authors as having correct attributions.  However, anybody looking at the data plots on diagrams such as that of Figure 4 must surely ask the same question as the one occurring to me --  "Surely there are such wide variations in these plots that the samples cannot possibly all have come from the same stone?"  The authors declare that they have a "high degree of confidence" that all attributions are correct, and they explain wide internal variations as  resulting from  patchy baryte cement distribution across parts of the Altar Stone surface, surface weathering variations, and heavy minerals located at different concentrations in discontinuous laminations.  All too convenient, with circular reasoning and special pleading never far away.........

Watch this space.......