The talk was entitled "Geology of Stonehenge and the Bluestone Controversy" and it covered the local geology of Salisbury Plain, the sarsens, the bluestones and (as a separate item) the Altar Stone controversy. As befits an Emeritus Professor, Peter did not pull his punches.
In the first section of his lecture Peter referred to his studies on the sarsens at Clatford Bottom and elsewhere and suggested that there was once a substantial litter of sarsens in the Stonehenge landscape, with many monoliths of different shapes and sizes used at Stonehenge for a monument which was never completed. Now where have we heard that before? He suggested a strong link with the remnants of the Reading Formation at Sidbury Hill and elsewhere and with the clay-with-flints deposits which are ubiquitous. He was not at all convinced by the work suggesting a West Woods source for many of the sarsens, and said that the obsession with working out haulage routes was "rather crazy."
The Zoom feed of this part of the lecture was very broken up, and I should like to know more about Peter's arguments......
On the bluestones, Peter expressed his support for the work of Judd, Kellaway, Burl and the OU team who all thought that the bluestones were glacially transported and derived from largely destroyed glacial deposits in the vicinity of Stonehenge. He seemed genuinely mystified as to why HH Thomas (a geologist) had in 1923 entered "fantasy land" by saying glacial transport of the bluestones was impossible and that human transport must therefore have happened. He was also mystified as to the reasons why geologists Ixer and Bevins had so enthusiastically "jumped into bed" with Parker Pearson and his team of archaeologists -- which he referred to as the establishment "mafia."
Peter referred to me and my books, and suggested that "The Stonehenge Bluestones" had been banned from the Reading University archaeology department and from the Stonehenge Visitor Centre. I don't know whether that is true, but I would not be surprised........ And his slide of him and me (referred to as "old codgers") in my bluestone museum from a few years ago is rather splendid.
The so-called bluestone quarries have been personally investigated in the field by Peter, and last evening he referred to the Carn Goedog and Craig Rhosyfelin quarries as "absolute nonsense" and "poppycock". He referred to the "mythical" Waun Mawn lost circle as "total fantasy". He accused the BBC, in that appalling Alice Roberts documentary, of a very serious dereliction of its duty and a decline of standards, saying that "the whole thing is fiction". And he sprang to my defence concerning the "really nasty" activities of Bevins and his lynch mob on the matter of the Newall Boulder. Their extraordinary behaviour, he said, brought them no credit whatsoever.
A reminder:
https://brian-mountainman.blogspot.com/2025/07/the-stonehenge-lynch-mob-marches-out.html
Turning to the wild twists and turns in the debate over the origin of the Altar Stone, he was again scathing about the poor quality of work done by Clarke and Kirkland, Bevins, Ixer and others. I got a clear impression that he was frustrated and even irritated by the premature publication of half-baked papers, by the use of surrogate samples, and by the lack of fieldwork. He was particularly critical of the "Dogger Land" hypothesis which predated the latest paper by Pirrie et al.
The outcome of all this, of course, is that we are no further forward now than we were in 1923 concerning the origin of the Altar Stone.
In his last section Peter also poured scorn on the paper by Clarke and Kirkland in which they claimed that the zircon evidence from Salisbury Plain stream sediments ruled out the glacial transport of materials onto Salisbury Plain from the west. He referred to the paper as "useless rubbish".
In his summary Peter accused the human transport proponents of "intransigence" and of having vested interests in keeping their hypothesis alive. There was, he said, an obsession with the telling of a good story, and a willingness to ignore or belittle inconvenient but sound scientific work in pursuit of that aim.
So there we are then.
By the way, I rather like being referred to as a "glacialist". Much more refined and genteel than being called a glaciologist or a geomorphologist.
On a personal note, it's gratifying that senior academics like Peter Worsley and Peter Kokelaar are now going on the record and speaking their minds. I know of many others who agree with them, but who prefer to keep silent because they are concerned about job security or because they think they do not know enough about the matter in hand to say anything meaningful. So here is a message to glacial geologists, geomorphologists and archaeologists everywhere -- for God's sake contribute to the debate, and call out nonsense when you see it!












