THE BOOK
Some of the ideas discussed in this blog are published in my new book called "The Stonehenge Bluestones" -- available by post and through good bookshops everywhere. Bad bookshops might not have it....
To order, click
HERE

Thursday, 10 October 2019

New Atlas Chapter now available




Superficial deposits and ecology / habitats in Pembrokeshire

As I never tire of saying, we will never fully understand the enigma of Stonehenge unless we also understand what happened "upstream" with regard to the ice stream that is suspected of entraining and transporting all those lumps of bluestone. We are referring to an hypothesis here -- and we must always accept that this may not be the truth -- but currently the evidence looks strong, and far stronger than anything brought forward in support of other hypotheses.

When I was asked to write the introductory chapter of the new Historical Atlas of Pembrokeshire I was happy to oblige -- and as I have mentioned before, it was published quite recently.  It's an awkward volume to get extracts from, because the book is a large-format square -- but I have now done some tweaking of my own copyright manuscript material, and have added the excellent maps drawn from my roughs by Anna Ratcliffe.

I'm very happy to give the Atlas some more publicity! Details:

Howell, D.W. (ed) 2019. An Historical Atlas of Pembrokeshire (Volume 5 of the Pembrokeshire County History). Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire County History Trust, 205 pp, £30.00.


Monday, 7 October 2019

Confusion reigns -- Late Devensian ice limits


This map of Late Devensian ("Newer Drift")  ice limits in South Wales was published in the GCR volume in 1989, and since then, many other limits have been proposed.   Confusion reigns.  I have been  involved in this chaos myself -- most recently in this blog.

In northern and western Pembrokeshire the evidence of relatively recent glaciation is now very strong, and it has been demonstrated that the old lines drawn by researchers prior to 1960 are fundamentally incorrect.    But the really big problem is that the  evidence of glaciation in the "south Pembrokeshire" is very subtle.  There are glacial deposits, and fluvioglacial deposits too -- but they are thin and patchy, and the consensus over the years is that they belong to the "Older Drift."  The Geological Survey still records them on the Geology of Britain viewer as Mid-Quaternary -- ie belonging to the Anglian Glaciation, or maybe even older.  in 1971 I proposed that most of mid-Pembrokeshire was glaciated in the Late Devensian, and that only the Castlemartin Peninsula and the southern coastal strip remained ice-free.  David Bowen, mindful of the considerable expanse of fluvioglacial gravels in the valley of the Western Cleddau as far south as Haverfordwest and Landshipping, suggested an ice spur projecting southwards from the Roch-Trefgarn ridge -- but this proposal has not had much support from anybody else.    But now I'm coming round to it, and I think DQB may be close to the truth.

The other thing that has happened is that I have been back to the southern and western coasts of Pembrokeshire, and am now convinced that all of them, at least as far east as Tenby, were affected by Late Devensian ice.  But how far inland did this ice actually push?

Well, the geology map shows patchy glacial and fluvioglacial sediments all over the place -- no part of Pembrokeshire is "peculiarly free" of these materials.


Above: The geological map of the mid west of Pembrokeshire.  This shows the extent of the sands and gravels on the flanks of the Western Cleddau valley -- while leaving open the possibility that they are all very ancient river terrace remnants that have nothing to do with glacial ice in the vicinity.  They may have been built up during past episodes of large-scale meltwater flow through the Trefgarn Gorge and thence southwards towards Milford Haven.  Work is needed on this.

The map shows that the tills described in my recent posts for the Nolton- Druidston coastal strip extend inland for maybe 500m or so, but no further.  But then another extensive area of till is shown further inland, and another to the NE of the A487 road.  Are these deposits related in age, or could they be much older?  And how many patches of till have been missed completely?

Never fear, dear reader.  I am on the case, and will report back shortly.


I am less and less convinced by the idea of a Late Devensian ice-free enclave........






Fresh melt-out till at Nolton Haven


The pretty bay of Nolton Haven is a dangerous place for scientific research because the foreshore is partly man-made -- there has been a lot of activity here, associated with coal-mining, shipping activities, and even the construction of a short-lived narrow gauge railway line.   I looked at one rather convincing exposure and found a piece of an earthenware flowerpot embedded within it.......

But one exposure is very safe -- close to the steps that run down to the beach in the NW corner.

The drift cliff here is around 10m high, and it displays several facies of fresh Devensian till.  The colour is buff - light brown, and in the lower part there is a much higher proportion of silt and sand than we see in most other exposures in the neighbourhood.    This is clearly seen in the photo above.   Above this there is a rapid transition into a much stonier facies, with the same suite of erratics including many of the rock types found at the outer end of the St Davids Peninsula and on Ramsey Island.  The cliff is capped with around 20 cm of sandy loam and soil.

 

In the lower part of the exposure there is one quite distinct silty layer which is relatively free of stones, and below that there is another facies of stony till. At the base of the section we see a blocky slope breccia up to 3-4m thick.  This breccia is also exposed in a more extensive exposure about 20m away and upslope.  Here the breccia is up to 5m thick.  At this site there is no blue-grey clay-rich Irish  Sea till (although it may occur in the valley near the car park); and neither is there any upper slope breccia capping the till.

The full sequence is as follows:

20 cms sandy loam and soil
1m of stony till (gravel and sand matrix -- high concentration of stones and boulders)
3m of more silty till with relatively few stones
15 cm thick silt layer -- relatively stoneless
1.5m of stony till with a sandy and gravelly matrix
3-4m of blocky slope breccia

Interpretation:  this is a deposit of melt-out or ablation till laid down at the end of the Late Devensian glacial episode, following the onset of ice wastage.



Devensian till at Madoc's Haven

View southwards across Madoc's Haven towards Druidston in the middle distance.  Virtually the while of this cliffline is capped by thin Devensian till.  Notice the large recent rockfall beneath the nearest cliff.  Note also the bevel on the clifftops.  I think this is an ancient feature, since the fresh till rests on the bevelled slope.

Madoc's Haven is an attractive and rather inaccessible bay (except at extreme low tide) between Druidston and Nolton Haven.  I walked along the clifftop yesterday, and was not at all surprised that there is fresh till capping the cliff almost continuously, over a distance of more than 1 km.

Wherever one can get close enough to take a look, the till layer is relatively thin (seldom over 2m thick) but quite undisturbed.  In places, there are traces of slope breccia beneath it, but there is never ant slope breccia above it.  It occurs up to the ground surface, with its top incorporated into  a layer of sandy loam and soil.  There is no upper slope breccia even where there is a modest slope leading down to the cliff edge.

Fresh till less than 50 cms thick, resting on broken bedrock, in a small stream valley crossed by the coast path, north of Druidston.  Above the till we see 50-60 cms of sandy loam.  Above that is the modern soil.  Intriguingly, there is a high percentage of rounded and sub-rounded pebbles in this till.

A fine exposure of till containing large striated erratics (many of them igneous) exposed in a stream cutting at the northern end of Madoc's Haven.   This till is over 2m thick, and is capped by sandy loam and soil.   Not far away there is another clifftop exposure  in which we can see 1.5 m of pseudo-stratified slope breccia beneath the till, but no slope breccia above. 

Heavily weathered and abraded igneous erratic near the exposure shown above.

I was struck, in examining these multiple exposures, that they look virtually the same as the clifftop exposures on the south coast of Pembrokeshire which I have featured in other posts.  The conclusion is inescapable -- both coastlines have been affected by encroaching glacier ice relatively recently -- in the Late Devensian.  All the signs are that this encroachment occurred around 26,000 years ago.

Devensian stratigraphy of Druidston Haven

Generalised sequence seen in the cliff today.  Much of the face is subject to slumping and is masked by vegetation.  In the north (left of the diagram) the slope breccia is invisible, having been covered by slumping and "flowage" of saturated Irish Sea till.

Druidston Haven, to the south of Rickets Head on the west-facing coast of St Bride's Bay, has been studied for many years and is one of the classic Quaternary sites of Wales.   The sequence of sediments is very similar indeed to that of Abermawr -- as indeed it should be, if it has experienced a similar Quaternary history.  I went down there yesterday to take a look, and examined it quite closely after enjoying a leisurely picnic in the sun.

The sequence shown in the diagram above is nowadays a little difficult to discern, because of extensive slumping of the clay-rich sediments and because of vegetation growth.  The raised beach is currently not visible, but I have seen it here in the past.

Wave-cut platform remnants at the northern edge of the pebble beach, near Priests Vault.  There is strong structural control associated with fracture planes.  Note the igneous giant erratic......

Cemented breccia (iron oxide and manganese oxide cement) resting on the rock platform.  Note the abraded inclusions.

One new feature, never recorded before, is a solidly cemented breccia made of sharp-edged fragments of black shale, resting on a remnant of an old raised beach or wave-cut platform, exposed in the northern corner of the main bay, where the present pebble beach buts against the cliffline.  There are two distinct platform remnants here, both affected by storm waves around present HWM.

I'm puzzled by the breccia, because it does not look like the fault breccia which is prominent just around the corner in the cliffs -- marking the edge of the Ordovician horst flanked by Coal Measures to the south and to the north.  The amount of displacement on the Simpson fault is c 1800m, so it is not surprising that there is a wide band of smashed-up rock or fault breccia here, prominently visible in the cliffs.  But I am confused because the limited exposures of this breccia suggest that it rests on a wave-cut platform, and it contains abraded stones and smaller pebbles which clearly have nothing at all to do with the tectonics along the fault line.  So I think this is a Quaternary deposit, made up mostly of shattered shale and mudstone fragments from the faulted debris exposed in the cliffs and with added inclusions which may have come from interglacial deposits -- either raised beach or slope breccia.

All of which brings us to comparisons with Broad Haven, not far to the south, and Whitesands, to the north-west, out at the tip of the St David's Peninsula.

https://brian-mountainman.blogspot.com/2019/02/the-full-whitesands-quaternary-sequence.html

At Whitesands, the cemented breccia is quite prominent, and elsewhere it can be seen to be associated with the raised beach.  So the most parsimonious explanation of it is that it is an interglacial deposit, laid down some time before the onset of the Devensian cold phase.  I see no evidence of a periglacial origin -- and I think the debris has accumulated as a result of "normal" rockfall and slope degradation processes.

I am getting more and more interested in these cemented deposits, as readers of this blog will know!

https://brian-mountainman.blogspot.com/2018/11/on-significance-of-cementation.html

At the southern end of the drift cliff, a sharp contact between slope breccia (the lowest visible stratum), made of broken sandstone and shale blocks from the adjacent cliffline, and stony Irish Sea till, coloured grey.  Modern pebble beach in the foreground.

Classic massive, stiff Irish Sea till exposed near the northern end of the cliff. There are relatively few pebbles and larger erratics in this till, assumed to be a lodgement till made mostly from dredged up sea floor materials.

The brown slope breccia is between 2m and 3m thick, and could be thicker in some places.   It does contain some erratics, but consists largely of broken sharp-edged fragments of Ordovician sandstones, quartzites and shales in a sandy and gravelly matrix.  There is no clear stratification, but the deposit is matrix-supported -- so it is best interpreted as a periglacial deposit accumulated over many thousands of years of cold climate.

It is overlain by clay-rich Irish Sea till, which has all the characteristics of a lodgement till in the northern part of the section but is more stony and gravelly elsewhere.  There is no clear junction between the lodgement till and the overlying stonier facies -- so the sedimentation process seems to have been unbroken, with the  facies change related to sediment supply and gradually changing glaciological conditions.  The overall thickness of the grey Irish Sea till is between 15m and 20m.  Here and there we see inclusions of patches of very stony till, suggestive of a dynamic ice wastage environment -- but there are no horizons of true fluvioglacial deposits.

A very stony facies of the Irish Sea till -- still grey in colour, but with an abundance of stones of all shapes and sizes, and many different lithologies including Cambian red and purple sandstones from near Caerfai and Caerbwdi.  This appears to be a lens of stony till surrounded by more clay-rich horizons.

Above the Irish Sea till we see 15m - 20m of brown melt-out or ablation till, full of stones of all shapes and sizes and containing many "super-erratics", many of which have fallen onto the pebble beach below.  Many others are exposed in the stream valley running inland from the coast.  There is no sharp junction between the Irish Sea till and the melt-out till.  In the latter there is considerable variation -- and signs of rough stratification in places, but the internal variations are quite subtle and the deposit cannot really be broken down into any meaningful sequence.  Some horizons are sandier and others are stonier, but there are no recognizable fluvio-glacial layers that might match those at Abermawr, and the till extends all the way to the clifftop, with no overlying slope breccia deposit.

Melt-out till at the top of the Druidston section.  There are some traces of stratification, and some lenses of stony till, but the stratification is discontinuous.

The top part of the exposure, showing true glacial deposits extending to the ground surface.  There is no sign here of periglacial rearrangement or redeposition.  The soil horizon contains some sandloess, and is c 20 cm thick.


What we have at Druidston is an impressive sequence of deposits representing a single glacial episode, which must be late Devensian in age, underlain by a slope breccia that probably represents the onset of cold conditions.  There is less variety here than at Abermawr, but the basic features of the story are the same.  And this site would be very rewarding indeed for studies of glacial sedimentation.


 Large erratic boulders (mostly igneous, from the outer part of St David's Peninsula) exposed in the stream cutting; and (below) the top of a super-erratic which I estimate to weigh more than 100 tonnes.


Note:  the deposit which I now refer to, with a degree of confidence, as "melt-out till"  was assumed for many years to be a soliflucted and rearranged  mixture of till and fluvioglacial sands and gravels and brecciated slope deposits.  It was referred to very often as "rubble drift" -- and indeed I used that label very frequently myself.  However, I am now convinced that it is a true glacial deposit in its original stratigraphic position, and that it is largely unmodified.    It was not formed by lodgement processes on a glacier bed, but by a much more complex set of englacial and supraglacial processes, probably in a dead-ice environment.

Sunday, 6 October 2019

Druidston then and now

The plug of Devensian till which fills the valley at Druidston (on the west-facing shore of St Bride's Bay) is famous as one of the key Quaternary sites of West Wales.  I was down there today, taking a look to see if there is anything new.  Indeed there is, of which more anon.  But this is how the "drift cliff" has changed between 1963 and the present day:


A monochrome photo of the cliff, taken while I was doing my doctorate research in field season 1963.  The cliff face is quite steep, with little surface vegetation.


The same cliff as it appears today.  The surface gradient has lessened, and there has been a great deal of slumping.  In turn, the reduced slopes have allowed vegetation to take hold 
across much of the face.

Wednesday, 2 October 2019

INQUA Scilly field trip cancelled


It's a pity that this INQUA Congress field trip planned for 1st-5th August 2019 had to be cancelled because of lack of bookings.  Mind you, at £845 for four days in the field, maybe there was a price issue.  The trip was due to be led by James Scourse, who was not best pleased when I published my short Isles of Scilly paper last year, in which I argued that the Devensian glaciation on the islands was much more extensive than he thought.  As far as I am concerned, the evidence for extensive glaciation during at least two glacial phases is now in print, and is rock solid, and it would have been good to get some more expert opinions from specialists with no axes to grind.

Ah well -- the evidence is still there for others to see, and I'm confident that it will eventually become "the established truth" no matter what the protests of the BRITICE-CHRONO boys and girls may be.........


Booking Blurb: 

The Isles of Scilly have been recognised as a classic Pleistocene locality for some 50 years following a seminal paper by Frank Mitchell and Tony Orme who mapped a clear ice limit across the archipelago. The excursion will review the stratigraphic and morphological evidence for this ice limit and review the application of combined dating methods recently used to constrain its age within the context of the BRITICE-CHRONO project. Sequences of glacial, periglacial, littoral, aeolian and full glacial organic sediments will be examined in open coastal cliff sections. Scilly is also exceptional archaeologically, described as the “Isles of the Dead” based on the profusion of burial structures, and the excursion will visit Mesolithic, Neolithic, Bronze Age and some more recent sites in the context of changing Holocene palaeoenvironments and relative sea level. The wealth of Quaternary geological and archaeological sites alongside great natural beauty – stunning beaches, crystal clear sea, benevolent climate with sub-tropical gardens – make Scilly a beguiling and enchanting place to visit for Quaternarists and accompanying participants alike. Please note that transport will be on foot on all days and will involve quite long treks over sometimes rough terrain; transport to off islands will be by boat taxi.