A new review of Herbert Thomas and his work has just been published in Antiquity journal. Was he a brilliant geologist, or a bit of a charlatan? I'll report on the detail in due course, but in the meantime here is the Abstract and the reference list -- the latter makes a good check-list of the papers by Bevins and Ixer. With a bit of luck, the hyperlinks will work........
(As we all know, I don't agree with the authors that they have definitively identified the locations from which some of the bluestones and the debitage at Stonehenge have come -- the best that can be said is that they have narrowed things down to the most likely neighbourhoods.)
==================
Retracing the footsteps of H.H. Thomas: a review of his Stonehenge bluestone provenancing study
Richard Bevins and Rob Ixer
Antiquity, May 2018.
Published online: 31 May 2018
Abstract
The long-distance transport of the Stonehenge bluestones from the Mynydd Preseli area of north Pembrokeshire was first proposed by geologist H.H. Thomas in 1923. For over 80 years, his work on the provenancing of the Stonehenge bluestones from locations in Mynydd Preseli in south Wales has been accepted at face value. New analytical techniques, alongside transmitted and reflected light microscopy, have recently prompted renewed scrutiny of Thomas's work. While respectable for its time, the results of these new analyses, combined with a thorough checking of the archived samples consulted by Thomas, reveal that key locations long believed to be sources for the Stonehenge bluestones can be discounted in favour of newly identified locations at Craig-Rhos-y-felin and Carn Goedog.
REFERENCES
- Bevins, R.E. & Ixer, R.A.. 2013. Carn Alw as a source of the rhyolitic component of the Stonehenge bluestones: a critical re-appraisal of the petrographical account of H.H. Thomas. Journal of Archaeological Science 40: 3293–301. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2013.03.017CrossRef | Google Scholar
Bevins, R.E., Lees, G.J. & Roach, R.A.. 1989. Ordovician intrusions of the Strumble Head-Mynydd Preseli region, Wales: lateral extensions of the Fishguard Volcanic Complex. Journal of the Geological Society of London 146: 113–23. https://doi.org/10.1144/gsjgs.146.1.0113CrossRef | Google Scholar
Bevins, R.E., Pearce, N.J.G. & Ixer, R.A.. 2011. Stonehenge rhyolitic bluestone sources and the application of zircon chemistry as a new tool for provenancing rhyolitic lithics. Journal of Archaeological Science 38: 605–22. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2010.10.014CrossRef | Google Scholar
Bevins, R.E., Ixer, R.A., Webb, P.C. & Watson, J.S.. 2012. Provenancing the rhyolitic and dacitic components of the Stonehenge Landscape bluestone lithology: new petrographical and geochemical evidence. Journal of Archaeological Science 39: 1005–19. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2011.11.020CrossRef | Google Scholar
Bevins, R.E., Ixer, R.A. & Pearce, N.J.G.. 2014. Carn Goedog is the likely major source of Stonehenge doleritic bluestones: evidence based on compatible element discrimination and principal component analysis. Journal of Archaeological Science 42: 179–93. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2013.11.009CrossRef | Google Scholar
Bevins, R.E., Atkinson, N., Ixer, R.A. & Evans, J.A.. 2017. U-Pb zircon age constraints for the Fishguard Volcanic Group and further evidence for the provenance of the Stonehenge bluestones. Journal of the Geological Society of London 174: 14–17. https://doi.org/10.1144/jgs2016-042CrossRef | Google Scholar
Cunnington, W. 1884. Stonehenge notes: the fragments. Wiltshire Archaeological and Natural History Magazine 21: 141–49.Google Scholar
Darvill, T. & Wainwright, G.. 2014. Beyond Stonehenge: Carn Menyn quarry and the origin and date of bluestone extraction in the Preseli Hills of south-west Wales. Antiquity 88: 1099–114. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003598X00115340CrossRef | Google Scholar
Darvill, T. & Wainwright, G.. 2016. Neolithic and Bronze Age Pembrokeshire, in James, H., John, M., Murphy, K. & Wainwright, G.(ed.) Pembrokeshire county history, volume 1, prehistoric, Roman and early medieval Pembrokeshire: 222–55. Haverfordwest: Pembrokeshire County History Trust.Google Scholar
Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. 1902. Summary of Progress of the Geological Survey of the United Kingdom and Museum of Practical Geology for 1901. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. 1903. Summary of Progress of the Geological Survey of the United Kingdom and Museum of Practical Geology for 1902. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. 1904. Summary of Progress of the Geological Survey of the United Kingdom and Museum of Practical Geology for 1903. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. 1905. Summary of Progress of the Geological Survey of the United Kingdom and Museum of Practical Geology for 1904. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. 1906. Summary of Progress of the Geological Survey of the United Kingdom and Museum of Practical Geology for 1905. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. 1907. Summary of Progress of the Geological Survey of Great Britain and Museum of Practical Geology for 1906. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. 1908. Summary of Progress of the Geological Survey of Great Britain and Museum of Practical Geology for 1907. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. 1909. Summary of Progress of the Geological Survey of Great Britain and Museum of Practical Geology for 1908. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. 1910. Summary of Progress of the Geological Survey of Great Britain and Museum of Practical Geology for 1909. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Geological Survey of the United Kingdom. 1921. Summary of Progress of the Geological Survey of Great Britain and Museum of Practical Geology for 1920. London: HMSO.Google Scholar
Harrison, R.K., Sanderson, B.W. & Hart, M.J.. 1979. Petrographical report: excavated rock fragments from Stonehenge and Silbury Hill. Institute of Geological Sciences Technical Report WG/PE/79/150.Google Scholar
Hawley, W. 1921. Stonehenge: interim report on the excavation. The Antiquaries Journal 1: 19–39. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003581500052975CrossRef | Google Scholar
Ixer, R.A. & Bevins, R.E.. 2010. The petrography, affinity and provenance of lithics from the Cursus Field, Stonehenge. Wiltshire Archaeological & Natural History Magazine 103: 1–15.Google Scholar
Ixer, R.A. & Bevins, R.E.. 2011a. Craig Rhos-y-felin, Pont Saeson is the dominant source of the Stonehenge rhyolitic debitage. Archaeology in Wales 50: 21–31.Google Scholar
Ixer, R.A. & Bevins, R.E.. 2011b. The detailed petrography of six orthostats from the Bluestone Circle, Stonehenge. Wiltshire Archaeological & Natural History Magazine 104: 1–14.Google Scholar
Ixer, R.A. & Bevins, R.E.. 2013. Chips off the old block: the Stonehenge debitage dilemma. Archaeology in Wales 52: 11–22.Google Scholar
Ixer, R.A. & Bevins, R.E.. 2016. Volcanic Group A debitage: its description and distribution within the Stonehenge Landscape. Wiltshire Archaeological & Natural History Magazine 109: 1–14.Google Scholar
Ixer, R.A., Bevins, R.E. & Gize, A.P.. 2015. Hard ‘volcanics with sub-planar texture’ in the Stonehenge Landscape. Wiltshire Archaeological & Natural History Magazine 108: 1–14.Google Scholar
Ixer, R.A., Turner, P., Molyneux, S. & Bevins, R.E.. 2017. The petrography, geological age and distribution of the Lower Palaeozoic sandstone debitage from the Stonehenge Landscape. Wiltshire Archaeological & Natural History Magazine 110: 1–16.Google Scholar
John, B., Ellis-Gruffydd, D. & Downes, J.. 2015. Quaternary events at Craig Rhosyfelin, Pembrokeshire. Quaternary Newsletter 137: 16–32.Google Scholar
Jones, O.T. 1966. Cerrig Llwydion Carn Meini. Y Gwyddonydd 4: 215–20.Google Scholar
Maskelyne, N.S. 1878. Stonehenge: the petrology of its stones. Wiltshire Archaeological and Natural History Magazine 17: 147–60.Google Scholar
Parker Pearson, M. 2015. Stonehenge: making sense of a prehistoric mystery. York: Council for British Archaeology.Google Scholar
Parker Pearson, M. 2016a. The sarsen stones of Stonehenge. Proceedings of the Geologists’ Association 127: 363–69.CrossRef | Google Scholar
Parker Pearson, M. 2016b. Secondhand Stonehenge? Welsh origins of a Wiltshire monument. Current Archaeology 311: 18–22.Google Scholar
Pearson, Parker, M., Bevins, R.E., Ixer, R.A., Pollard, J., Richards, C., Welham, K., Chan, B., Edinborough, K., Hamilton, D., Mcphail, R., Schlee, D., Schwenninger, J.-L., Simmons, E. & Smith, M.. 2015. Craig Rhos-y-felin: a Welsh bluestone megalith quarry for Stonehenge. Antiquity 89: 1331–52. https://doi.org/10.15184/aqy.2015.177CrossRef | Google Scholar
Parker Pearson, M., Bevins, R.E., Ixer, R.A., Pollard, J., Richards, C. & Welham, K.. In press. Long-distance landscapes: from quarries to monument at Stonehenge, in Mataloto, R. (ed.) Megaliths and geology: proceedings of a conference in memory of Rui Boaventura. Redondo: Centro Cultural do Redondo.Google Scholar
Parkinson, J. 1897. Some igneous rocks in north Pembrokeshire. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 53: 465–76. https://doi.org/10.1144/GSL.JGS.1897.053.01-04.37CrossRef | Google Scholar
Part, G.M. 1922. Notes on the Ordovician lavas of Mynydd Prescelly, north Pembrokeshire. Geological Magazine 54: 310–23. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0016756800109884CrossRef | Google Scholar
Teall, J.J.H. 1894. Notes of sections of Stonehenge rocks belonging to Mr W. Cunnington. Wiltshire Archaeological and Natural History Magazine 27: 66–68.Google Scholar
Thomas, H.H. 1923. The source of the stones of Stonehenge. The Antiquaries Journal 3: 239–60. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003581500005096CrossRef | Google Scholar
Thorpe, R.S., Williams-Thorpe, O., Jenkins, D.G. & Watson, J.S., with contributions by Ixer, R.A. & Thomas, R.G.. 1991. The geological sources and transport of the bluestones of Stonehenge, Wiltshire, UK. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society 57: 103–57.CrossRef | Google Scholar
10 comments:
I see Richard Bevins is the author for correspondance.
I think that Richard and Rob seem to alternate the honour.....
Hi gang (of two),
I had benefit of reading the above review prior to its release. One of the authors leaned more toward the denigration of Thomas for the lack of follow-up. I begged to differ with regard to a couple of points, and so Thomas was presented in a less-caustic light.
Thomas essentially wandered through that part of Wales as a much younger man, picking up rocks and ruminating on the similarities between them and those at Stonehenge. But he never went back and subsequently went about living his life.
Twenty years later he learned (through a request) that others were about to publish an in-depth analysis and decided to nip it in the bud by publishing his own analysis, based on a thesis he'd cooked up when he was younger.
He got the source-locations wrong, but not the vicinity. But in no way could his published supposition be construed as hubris, rather for wanting to be remembered for something he would never have achieved in his present, somewhat mundane career. And thus he is.
Was Thomas the sharpest tool in the shed? By no means, but what was essentially an extended stroll through the wilds of Pembrokeshire by a man who was enjoying the scenery, turned out to be a watershed event in provenancing the Blues at Stonehenge. The details of his position paper are flawed, yes. But the overall thesis turns out to be spot-on.
Best,
Neil
Neil -- you imply that HHT was a bumbling amateur who wandered around just looking at things. He was not-- he was a professional geologist who worked for the BGS and who was involved in all of the key memoirs for South Wales, as well as writing assorted specialist papers published in learned journals.
On the contrary, Brian, I imply no such thing. Thomas was very accomplished. But when he wandered around Wales as a younger man, he had not yet risen to his later position.
Gang of TWO? Not based upon the number of folk visiting this site each day!! Welcome to the UK in a few days, Neil. Enjoy reading the book - MANY people already are, a few days after official publication. Incidentally. a friend (another glacial hypothesis champion) has just received his SECOND copy via the national bookshop, Waterstones. That was near Bournemouth and Souuthampton, so all you professional archaeologists and students based at Southampton and Bournemouth now know they can do the same.
Neil is just being mischievous -- we get over 11,000 page views per month, so there are presumably quite a few followers out there, tuning in when it suits them......
Thank you Tony. It'll be my second visit in 9 months. The Stones at Solstice. Oh ... joy.
Is it possible we have a mutual friend in Bournemouth? The gent I know is currently visiting the Emerald Isle, but reports favorably on the book.
You've made quite a splash this time, Brian, I must say. Several people have contacted me, breathlessly announcing this 'New Idea!' from some guy in Wales with two first names ...
You have readers, my friend -- and some of them have voices.
Another mutual friend of ours in Brum is also, er, reading it. We have a lunch date on the 19th and I expect a full report. I'll pick up my copy from Waterstones.
I won't have time to make it to Wales this visit, Brian, so you're off the hook from this annoying troll. Maybe see you in September.
Best wishes to all,
Neil
You a troll, Neil? Never -- your comments are far too well-informed and well-considered. And always welcome.
You might just have to order the book from Waterstones -- that esteemed company has not (so far) ordered the book for its "hub" so that all branches can stock it, and as I understand it each order is dealt with separately. But the more people who ask for it, the more likely it is to be stocked. It's a tough commercial world out there.......
Let me know when you do manage a trip to Wales, and we can take a look at a few key sites...
Wonderful if we can encourage Waterstones to stock the new BJ book via its central "hub". Then all those shy archaeologists may obtain it "anonymously" without Brian finding out they are buying copies!!
Post a Comment