THE BOOK
Some of the ideas discussed in this blog are published in my book called "The Bluestone Enigma" -- available by post and through good bookshops everywhere. Bad bookshops might not have it....
To order, click
HERE

Saturday, 30 August 2014

Icy breath in Death Valley



This is fun -- one of the strangest natural mysteries appears to have been solved.  We never cease to be amazed by natural processes the consequences of which which have been observed and puzzled over, but not previously understood.......

So here we are in Death Valley, one of the hottest places on Earth, having to come to terms with the work of ice.

These boulders, on surfaces with hardly any gradient, appear to move along for no apparent reason, leaving long trails behind them.  The work of aliens?  The trouble is that people have normally looked at them in the summer, when temperatures can be up over 40 degrees C.  The research team decided to look at them in the winter, when temperatures are often well below zero -- and lo and behold, they saw them move!  What happens is that very thin sheets (just a few mm) of ice form on the saturated playa floor, with temperatures sometimes not low enough for freezing down to the ground beneath.  So the thin ice sheets rest on a film of water, and when the wind blows, the ice sheets move gently, applying enough pressure on stones and boulders to overcome friction and move them too.  There isn't much friction because the playa floor sediments are saturated and slushy -- so the stones move along and leave "plough marks" behind them.  In the spring, the water all evaporates away, and desert conditions reappear, and lots of people come along and take photos like the one above!

Here are two other images from the original research paper, showing how changes of wind direction cause the thin ice sheets to move in different directions:





 One rock moved 224m during a single winter.  Notice that not all the stones and boulders were moved during the period of observations.  Individual stone movement depends on a variety of factors -- including the depth to which it is embedded in the sediments, the mobility of the slushy surface layer, the depth of the water film, the thickness and coherence of the ice sheet, and the strength and persistence of the wind. 

================================

This is a report from the Nature web site, with a link to the article itself in PlosOne journal:

http://www.nature.com/news/wandering-stones-of-death-valley-explained-1.15773

Nature | News

'Wandering stones' of Death Valley explained
Scientists spot ice shoving rocks on Racetrack Playa in California, resolving a longstanding geological enigma.

Alexandra Witze
27 August 2014

Richard Norris & Jim Norris

Ending a half-century of geological speculation, scientists have finally seen the process that causes rocks to move atop Racetrack Playa, a desert lake bed in the mountains above Death Valley, California. Researchers watched a pond freeze atop the playa, then break apart into sheets of ice that — blown by wind — shoved rocks across the lake bed.

Until now, no one has been able to explain why hundreds of rocks scoot unseen across the playa surface, creating trails behind them like children dragging sticks through the mud.

“It’s a delight to be involved in sorting out this kind of public mystery,” says Richard Norris, an oceanographer at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography in La Jolla, California, who led the research with his cousin James Norris, an engineer at Interwoof in Santa Barbara, California. The work was published on 27 August in PLoS ONE1.

Geologists previously speculated that some combination of wind, rain and ice would have a role. But few expected that the answer would involve ice as thin as windowpanes, pushed by light breezes rather than strong gales.

Visitors to Death Valley have to go out of their way to visit Racetrack Playa, which sits 1,130 metres above sea level and is a bumpy three-hour drive from the nearest town. The researchers began studying the region in 2011, setting up a weather station and time-lapse cameras and dropping off rocks loaded with Global Positioning System (GPS) trackers. The rocks were designed to start recording their position and speed as soon as something made them move.

What was not clear was how long the Norrises would have to wait. Ralph Lorenz, a planetary scientist at the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory in Laurel, Maryland, has been studying the playa since 2007 as an analogy to lake beds on other planets. He had little faith that the GPS-equipped rocks would move in a time frame that anyone would capture. “I thought it was going to be the most boring experiment in the history of science,” he says.

But when the researchers travelled to the playa in December 2013 to check instruments and change batteries, they found a huge ice-encrusted pond covering about one-third of the 4.5-kilometre-long playa. After several days of camping, they decided to sit above the southern end of the playa on the morning of 20 December. “It was a beautiful sunny day, and there began to be rippled melt pools in front of us,” Richard Norris says. “At 11:37 a.m., very abruptly, there was a pop-pop-crackle all over the place in front of us — and I said to my cousin, ‘This is it.’ ”

They watched as the ice began moving past the rocks, mostly breaking apart but also shoving them gently. The rocks began to inch along, but their pace was too slow to spot by eye. “A baby can get going a lot faster than your average rock,” Richard Norris says.

But when the ice melted away that afternoon, they saw freshly formed trails left behind by more than 60 moving rocks. And on 9 January, James Norris returned to the playa with Lorenz and was able to record video of the roving rocks. “This is transformative,” says Lorenz. “It’s not just an anecdotal report, but we have before and after pictures, and meteorological information simultaneous with the event.” By the end of the winter, the farthest-moving rock had travelled 224 metres.

Racetrack Playa rocks move rarely — “maybe a few minutes out of a million,” Lorenz says. And the two events the scientists saw, with thin ice panes shoving the stones across a wet playa, do not necessarily explain every instance of rocks moving there. “But this breaks the back of the problem scientifically,” Lorenz says. “It is ice shove.”

Solving the Racetrack Playa mystery is not exactly a major scientific breakthrough, Lorenz says, but the work does show the rare combination of conditions that allow rocks to move seemingly on their own. And ice shove can have notable effects — in 1952, it uprooted enough telephone poles at a lake in Nevada to break a transcontinental telephone line.

One person who is happy to see the latest results is Dwight Carey. As a university student in the 1970s, he helped with an experiment in which two rocks were placed in a corral on the playa. Over the course of a winter, one stone moved out of the corral, unobserved, and the other did not 2.

The new explanation “makes sense to me”, says Carey, who is now an environmental regulatory consultant in Brea, California. “Eventually you’re going to get enough force on the pile of ice behind the rocks to be able to move them.”

References

Norris, R. D., Norris, J. M., Lorenz, R. D., Ray, J. & Jackson, B. PLoS ONE 9, e105948 (2014).
http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0105948

Sharp, R. P. & Carey, D. L. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 87, 1704–1717 (1976).




16 comments:

Constantinos Ragazas said...

Brian,

Use the “search” function of your own blog to find my post here of some three years ago with a link to my “rough calculations” proving a 3 ton megalith on a flat ice surface (e.g. a frozen glacier lake) can be moved by a 60 mph wind. Here is that link again in case you misplaced it!

http://thefacultypublishinggroup.com/Archeology/Stonehenge%20Problem%20B.pdf

The researcher of this discovery states ”rocks moved under light winds of about 3-5 meters per second (10 miles per hour) and were driven by ice less than 3-5 millimeters (0.25 inches) thick”

[http://phys.org/news/2014-08-mystery-stones-death-valley-action.html]

Kostas

BRIAN JOHN said...

Bang on schedule, a comment, as expected, from the ever-vigilant Kostas! Don't get too euphoric here. Sure, this is an interesting piece of work, but the physical laws at work are not that difficult to understand. A 3-tonne megalith sitting on a frozen lake surface, being blown along by a 6o mph wind? I don't think so. Think skating and curling. These stones were not blown along by the wind -- they were bulldozed along by sheets of ice which were themselves mobilized by the wind and as a consequence of the extremely low friction on the lower surface of the ice.

AG said...

Surely they were moved by man? Guided by the spirit of age old Alexandrians?

BRIAN JOHN said...

Ah, the spirits of the ancestors. Pssst -- there's a quarry just round the corner, off the edge of the photo......

BRIAN JOHN said...

Ah, the spirits of the ancestors. Pssst -- there's a quarry just round the corner, off the edge of the photo......

Myris of Alexandria said...

Scoffers, Mons Claudianus is just down the river.
So both Brian and Kostas believe the stones were brought by wind. You can't make it up.
M

BRIAN JOHN said...

Kostas -- comment blocked. Not going over all this again.

I think the stones were brought by wind? Myris -- you just made that up.

Myris of Alexandria said...

"oh yes you did"
I grant you not a zephyr more the breath of Skiron.
"Some are born great, some achieve greatness and some have quarries thrust upon them".
M

Constantinos Ragazas said...

Brian,

You can't initiate a discussion and then deny a response to it. As for Myris, he has come a long way from Alexandria and believing in Apollo to London and believing in MPP. So sad to see a good man go wrong for the love of others.

Kostas

BRIAN JOHN said...

As I understand it, the wind moves the ice, and the ice moves the stones. Different thing entirely -- a very strange set of circumstances.

BRIAN JOHN said...

Kostas -- new discussions are fine. Old and tired ones make me irritable!

chris johnson said...

I have been intrigued by this for years. Glad to have the explanation.

Any ideas on crop circles, anybody?

Myris of Alexandria said...

Sometimes I am reminded of the pre-nuptial gift from sublime Apollo to Cassandra, or rather His supplementary gift.
But truth will out(that is for you Kostas).
Is there not the same thing in the Atacarma desert.
M

Constantinos Ragazas said...

Myris,

In a conversation with a good friend of mine long time ago, I likened myself to a desert cactus. Just a droplet of truth at the crack of dawn is enough to sustain me through long dry spells.

As for Cassandra, I would rather know the truth and not be believed than make up stories for others to believe.

Kostas

Myris of Alexandria said...

What is the collective noun for Cassandras?
Brian and Kostas and dear Myris all believe themselves to be her avatar.

I suggest an incredulance.

Tim Daw' s co-authored paper is short and a good read, or see Mike Pitts' report on his blog Digging deeper.

Myris.

TonyH said...

Hey, Mr Tambourine Man,
The Answer, my friends, is blowin' in the wind......
The Truth IS out there...
Speak to my friend Kostas...

I'm stuck inside of Mobile
With the Memphis (Myris?) blues again
Watchin' these mobile rocks
Racin' one another
While the sun beats down
Mercilessly
All I need now
Is a real good toon