Some of the ideas discussed in this blog are published in my new book called "The Stonehenge Bluestones" -- available by post and through good bookshops everywhere. Bad bookshops might not have it....
To order, click

Sunday, 4 March 2018

Coygan Cave rhyolite axe

Found this fabulous image of the famous axe from Coygan Cave, near Laugharne.   Click to enlarge.

Made from rhyolite.  Which rhyolite?  Where from?  Assumed to be of Palaeolithic date -- and possibly Neanderthal........

Curator's Choice: Elizabeth Walker of National Museum Cardiff chooses a Stone Age axe

Elizabeth Walker interviewed by Chris Broughton | 01 February 2009 |Updated: 01 February 2011

Curator's Choice: In her own words... Elizabeth Walker, Curator of Palaeolithic & Mesolithic Archaeology at National Museum Cardiff talks about a Neanderthal hand axe made of rhyolite, which dates back to c. 60,000-35,000 BC.

"This is a hand axe found during excavations at Coygan Cave, near Laugharne, Carmarthenshire, in advance of the cave's destruction by quarrying in the 1960s. It is of a form typically made by a Neanderthal and was left at the cave with another similar tool sometime between 60,000 and 35,000 years ago.

Findings like this hint that Neanderthals may have lived in the Carmarthenshire area, but we have no evidence of their physical remains. The two axes we have were found near the wall of the cave, and it’s been suggested they were deliberately cached by their owners, who intended to return to the cave to use them on a future visit.

What happened to those owners is unknown, as we have no Neanderthal remains of this date from sites in Wales. It’s interesting to speculate, though. Perhaps they were passing through and sheltered in the cave for the night, before setting off down the valley the following morning to hunt big game.

This is a particularly good example of a Neanderthal hand axe. Real, true Neanderthal tools tend to be beautifully crafted, and very distinctive in their shape and form, quite unlike those made by their hominim ancestors. There’s a sense that this was made with a certain amount of pride.

The axe has been hewn out of a chunk of rhyolitic tuff. Typically, Neanderthal tools were made from flint, but there’s no good flint source in Wales, so the maker has had to use an alternative, locally available material.

Rhyolite isn’t as fine-grained as flint, and doesn’t flake in quite such a crisp way. As a result, this axe doesn’t have quite the same sharp flake scars you’d see on a tool made from a more siliceous stone. Even so, the maker has shown considerable skill in working this comparatively difficult material – the axe still has all the characteristics you’d usually expect to see in a tool of this type.

To begin with, the stone would have been knocked into shape using a hard, percussive hammer-like instrument, perhaps a pebble. The thinner, finer flakes would have been removed using a softer material such as bone or antler – you can really see the affect of that across the surface of the object.

Neanderthals are fascinating. They shared a common ancestor with us, yet they were an evolutionary dead-end and died out sometime after anatomically modern humans like ourselves entered Britain. It’s a very strange sensation to look at a tool made by a Neanderthal and consider that it was essentially made by a different species.

A lot of work has been done about the ways Neanderthals’ brains may have worked, and it is now thought that they had the capacity to express themselves through song. I’ve been working with a local composer, Simon Thorne, who has picked up on this idea and created a soundscape to play in the museum’s Origins gallery, in the area where we display the hand axe.

The idea was to provide an imagined landscape of what sounds a Neanderthal may have both made and heard, and I know Simon gained a certain amount of inspiration from handling this axe and visiting the caves like the one in which it was discovered."


Gordon said...

What we're going to do right here is go back,way back,back into time.

chris johnson said...

There is a photo on the museum site showing Elizabeth holding the axe. It is much bigger than the Neanderthal "hand axes" I have handled. I wonder why she sounds so sure of the dating.

Actually one of the puzzles around Neanderthals are why their tools are so small and fine while they were a big strong people.

I am also curious why she thinks neanderthal tools tend to be beautifully crafted. Nearly everything I have seen gives the impression of being opportunistically gathered and quickly fashioned for functionality, e.g. for harvesting a kill.

Her point about Neanderthals having died out is open for discussion with DNA evidence suggesting a few percent Neanderthal in all western europeans today, about half what it was in the mesolithic. Quite likely that Neanderthal and homo sapiens merged.

chris johnson said...

I sent a comment through a couple of days ago. Did you get it?

Gordon said...

He must have been in such a rush to get to the Eisteddfod he left his axe behind.

TonyH said...

'Boffin* looks to Wales for Neanderthal blood - Wales Online' [mentions the so - called "Neanderthal twins" of the 19th Century from near Strata Florida and Tregaron].>NewsWalesNews

* an Oxford University PhD academic of some repute

Does anyone recall the appearance of the Arsenal defenders of the George Graham era? Sturdy chaps, didn't say much. Action spoke louder than words.

BRIAN JOHN said...

That's an ancient article, Tony! From 2006.......... hooray for the good people of Tregaron...... and whatever happened to boffins?