THE BOOK
Some of the ideas discussed in this blog are published in my new book called "The Stonehenge Bluestones" -- available by post and through good bookshops everywhere. Bad bookshops might not have it....
To order, click
HERE

Monday, 27 June 2022

The Preseli Roman Road -- a hypothesis in search of some evidence


This is a strange article -- thanks to Dave for sending it to me.  Some weeks ago we covered the advance press release, which as also very strange........

The Golden Road: Fact, Fable, Flemish, or ‘Flavian’?
Mark Merrony, Antiqvvs, Summer 2022, pp 25-34


Anyway, in this piece Mark Merrony discusses the documentary and "folk memory" aspects of the ancient trackwasy along the Preseli ridge, variously describes as the Golden Road, the Flemings Way, a Roman Road a a few more things besides.  It's a strange article, which could well have been cut in half -- since most of it consists of a somewhat self-indulgent description of springtime ramblings with a mountain bike across the landscape, with the author searching for depressions, sunken lanes, trackways, and anything that might indicate the presence of a Roman Road.  There are some nice photos and there are indeed many short sections of old rutted trackways, some of which I know well.  But nowhere does the author show that these are anything other than segments of ancient  routeways including bits of the old drovers' routes and also forestry tracks created at the times of forestry planting, maintenance and harvesting.  Heavy military vehicles used this area for training during WW2.  Some "sunken" sections have been deeepened by serving as streambeds during periods of heavy rain. No evidence is presented to show that the trackway was a single continuous route; no evidence is presented to show that it was paved or properly engineered; and no evidence is presented of a Roman connection.

Much speculation, made worse by gratuitous mentions of bluestones and bluestone haulage, again on the basis of no evidence whatsoever.  

Perhaps Mark will come back to us again when he actually has some evidence?


6 comments:

Tony Hinchliffe said...

Well, we have this speculation from an M.M, so will a certain notorious MPP leap upon this, stand on his shoulders as he did with Geoffrey Wainwright, and present some more of his UCL - style " disruptive thinking"? Forgive me for my note of scepticism...we, be a seen it all, many, many times, Mike

chris johnson said...

I see Mark Merrony is Editor in Chief of this new magazine. If nothing else he has a talent for promotion. Stonehenge and the bluestones seldom disappoint.

BRIAN JOHN said...

Well, what,s the point of being an editor if you can't publish your own stuff?

Penrodyn said...

I saw that post as well, thought it was strange at the time.

Anonymous said...

This all seems to be rather negative.

BRIAN JOHN said...

Well, yes -- it would be nice to have some evidence.......