I have posted on the geology of the island before:
https://brian-mountainman.blogspot.com/2016/01/ramsey-island-geology.html
https://brian-mountainman.blogspot.com/2015/01/ramsey-island-as-major-source-of.html
The darker coloured "giant erratic" on Ramsey Sound may have come from further north on the island; one of the boulders in the Storrie Collection (from Pencoed in Glamorgan) is assigned by Bevins and Donnelly to one of the volcanic debris flow outcrops of Ramsey; and it may be that some of the fine-grained lava erratics from St Bride's Haven are also from Ramsey. Somebody needs to do a systematic study.
Might the Limeslade erratic also have come from Ramsey? I have some doubts about that, since the initial analyses suggest it is a metamorphosed coarse dolerite with a greenish colour, and I don't think such a rock type exists on Ramsey Island. Watch this space.......
So if, as seems highly likely, large numbers of erratics have been entrained from Ramsey Island, it's intriguing that there are no obvious plucking or quarrying sites on the lee (or downglacier) flank. The boulders -- sometimes weighing hundreds of tonnes -- have apparently been incorporated into the ice on the western and south-western hill masses, perhaps with later moulding removing all traces of the "extraction locations."
This suggests to me that the assumption (which we often see in the literature) of moulding on the upglacier flanks of obstacles, and plucking (and erratic entrainment) on the downglacier flanks, is not very reliable. The island does not have an obvious roche moutonnee shape. I have of course also suggested that bluestone erratic entrainment on Preseli happened preferentially on the northern -- or up-glacier -- side of Mynydd Preseli, and I have discussed this at some length with various glacial geomorphology colleagues. Again, watch this space......
You say " watch this space" as regards the provenance of the Limeslade ( Gower coast) erratic. This is your first mention of the Limeslade erratic since early May 2022, over 12 months ago. Have you had any updates about its geological composition since May 2022?
ReplyDeleteYes, there is progress at last -- the snail's pace is very frustrating, but we are dependent upon the goodwill of very busy people. Before long we should have both geochemistry and petrography to report.
ReplyDeletePraise the Lord! But, equally, geological time is phenomenally long too.
ReplyDeleteYou must inform the Welsh Government as soon as the scientific reports emerge, Brian.
ReplyDeleteDon't quite follow -- to what purpose?
ReplyDelete...just for propaganda and/or morale boosting purposes. There should at least be a full male voice choir gathered around said Mumbles erratic, if not indeed a Max Boyce lookalike or a Tom Jones genuine article.
ReplyDeleteFair enough. Let's go the whole hog and have an annual "Erratic Wales Festival".........
ReplyDelete